Showing posts with label 2008. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2008. Show all posts

Sunday, April 27, 2014

The Oxford Murders (2008)

There is much to laugh at in “The Oxford Murders,” a serial murder thriller mixing in philosophy, math, and Frodo (Elijah Wood) as a hunk of smooth manliness wooing the English ladies with spaghetti and meatball themed sex. Not intended as a comedy, this flick is hilarious. Wood stars an American student who puts all his life into entering Oxford U to study under John Hunt’s wild-haired fruit loop professor’s logic class only to learn after his arrival on campus that the professor has retired from teaching. The kid is stunned. Really? Adults wrote and directed. The adults are Jorge Guerricaechevarria and Álex de la Iglesia (real names?) and they dish up all the genre thriller clichés sprinkled with inane philosophical babble and algorithm riddles that only nerds must think clever, with Wood – I must mention this again – as the stud wooing woman thrillingly open to pasta experimentation. Might all this be satire? Dig Jim Carter’s inspector who slowly catches on that serial murderers kill multiple victims. Dud. D+

Sunday, July 7, 2013

21 (2008)

“21” -– based on a true-story -– is a casino heist film of a different color, relying on card-counting for its anti-heroes to steal from the rich. Speaking of color, the characters onscreen are of a different color too, as the real suspects were Asian-Americans. On film, it’s WASPed up the nil. (Producers say they tried really hard to find college-age Asian actors.) But I digress. The story: MIT math geek Ben (Jim Sturgess) digs the class held by a snarky professor (Kevin Spacey) and is soon asked to join the man’s off-hours Blackjack Club. But it’s a con, and the prof has his students pulling down Vegas casinos in front of all seeing eyes, two of which belong to Laurence Fishburne. Will Ben, a good lower-middle-class boy with an hourly job and a wish to attend Harvard Med, wake up from his Gordon Gekko dive and do good? Put aside the race issue, we’re watching an Eagle Scout build a fire with flashy editing, loud music, and the lure of sex stewing faux suspense to make us forget the guy’s a freakin’ Eagle Scout. The ending is so upbeat happy, Ben could be Roy Hobbs. C+

Thursday, April 4, 2013

X-Files: I Want to Believe (2008)

I watched the supernatural “X-Files” TV series with so-so religious devotion, and the 1998 “X-Files: Fight the Future” film was well-timed, bringing back paranormal FBI agent investigators Mulder (David Duchovny) and Scully (Gillian Anderson). Yet, by the time “X-Files: I Want to Believe” came 10 years later, I was over the show. So seem the actors and creator/director Chris Carter. This is a “stand-alone” episode, not just in theme, but time. It’s more akin to “Se7en.” Not anything to obsess over. Here, Scully works miserably at a Catholic hospital, while Mulder clips news articles and miserably grows a beard. A perplexing case involving a missing FBI agent, a severed arm, and a psychic criminal priest (Billy Connolly) brings our heroes back to flashlights in the dark and grisly conspiracies, and as the mystery is uncovered, the limits of PG-13 ratings are stretched as is any semblance of logic: A hero hears dogs barking in No Where West Virginia and instantly recognizes the bad guy’s lair. Really? No one here has been to West Virginia, the snow screams Canada. Believe? My faith vanished long ago. C+

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Killing Them Softly (2012)

Brad Pitt's grim crime thriller “Killing Them Softly” already has much box office notoriety: A money loser slapped with an “F” from CinemaScore. Hell with that. This is ballsy filmmaking of the highest order. Andrew Dominik -– who made “Assassination of Jesse James” with Pitt -– is behind “KSF” as director/writer, and he is not out to please anyone. We follow two low-end criminals (Scoot McNairy and Ben Mendelsohn) who rob a mafia-run card game, and escape with cash in hand and angry men in pursuit, one of them a world-weary hit man played by Pitt. “KSF” is set in 2008, during the economic meltdown and Obama/McCain election, and Dominik uses the panic and uncertainty of the time to explode the panic and uncertainty onscreen. There are no heroes, jokes, or happy endings. It’s a devastating punch about real criminal life, peppered with sad-sacks, drug-users, and average joes in over their heads. Not necessarily evil. Unintended fuck-ups. Dominik dares say our politicians, Wall Street bankers, and Founding Fathers are/were no different. It's the American way. Even a tedious slow-mo killing and oddball fireworks scene can’t hide that “KSF” is shockingly true cinematic art. A-

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

The Fall (2008) and Mirror, Mirror (2012)

Indian-born director Tarsem Singh’s gift of visual story-telling is near unsurpassed. He goes bolder and bigger than most filmmakers dare dream. Yet, his movies mostly are cinematic affairs for the eyes, with the brain left to defend for itself. “Cell” (2000) and “Immortals” (2011) fall in those categories. So goes it with two other of his films I watched back-to-back: “Mirror, Mirror,” a new take on “Snow White,” and “The Fall,” a fairy tale possibly aimed at adults who prefer movies weird and wireder.

“Mirror” only pretends to be a subversive take on the famous Grimm Fairytale as the opening minutes has Julia Roberts as the Evil Queen going all snarky on her Fairest of Them All step-daughter (Lily Collins), during a voice-over with some wildly cool stop-motion animation. I thought we were in for a dark cinematic upside-down cake treat: The story of a misunderstood queen about a poison-apple princess brat. But, no. It’s the same story told by Walt Disney and onward, but made so bright and fluffy, and with such movie set fakery, it smells of some flippant meta-movie joke against ticket-buying parents.

Only one scene involving marionette assassins after Snow and her dwarves hypes eye-popping Tarsem magic. The rest of the running time is dull as slush. Yes, Roberts has a hoot dishing one-lines and cruel judgments with a wide smile, but she’s never playing anything else than some inner-joke take on her apparent prima-donna spoiled movie star self. I can only guess her direction likely consisted of, “Just be yourself! But more!” 

Collins is drab, and -– cruel to say, I know -– not a bit fair. When she’s onscreen, the film dives, even during an early ball scene where Collins wears a white goose dress that strangely echoes Bjork’s Oscar outfit from 2000. Did Robert stipulate in her contact that she had to be the fairest and best-dressed on the set? One wonders. 

As the Prince, Armie Hammer (“SocialNetwork”) throws himself forehead deep into the role of a buffoon. At one point, he plays puppy love. Literally. Barking, panting and whining. I felt bad for him. C-

“Fall” is a fairytale adventure set inside the unlimited mind of an imaginative, wildly curious 6-year-old girl. It’s lovely to look at, a film unlike any that I have ever seen. Yet, that’s the kicker of this epic in-every-sense-of-the-word story. Director/co-writer Tarsem spent four years in two dozen countries making his film and every bit of work is onscreen. It’s all and only visual. It’s a shame “Fall” is not a solid film to put all the senses to work. 

The setup: Circa 1914, a movie stuntman (Lee Pace) lays bedridden at a Los Angeles sanitarium, injured after an onset incident has left him unable to walk. Riddled with anger, and heartbreak because his Hollywood girlfriend has left him for another man, Roy decides on suicide. He befriends a young girl (Catinca Untaru), herself recovering from a broken arm, and tells her a long, twisting tale about four adventurers (Pace among them, as The Masked Bandit) each seeking a kill-or-be-killed revenge vendetta against an evil king (Daniel Caltagirone, also playing the “another man.”) 

Untaru’s youngster listens, and we see the visuals inside her head played out on screen, including her mistaken rendering of an “Indian” as a warrior from India, not Roy’s intended stereotype of a Native American. There’s action, adventure, kidnapping, sword-fights, swimming elephants, an assassinated monkey, castles, desert landscapes, and lush jungles, all peopled by workers and residents surrounding the girl at the hospital. There’s Charles Darwin, too, a swashbuckling hero. Less-than-honest Roy has a hidden motive as spins his tale: He wants his young friend to bring him morphine pills from the supply closet. That’s his path to suicide bliss. 

It all mostly sounds very similar to a children’s film, certainly the plot is childlike, but the graphic violence is tough, and the film takes a hard-to-swallow tearjerker finale far too dark and violent for anyone younger than, say, 14. Who knows who Tarsem is targeting with all this doom and gloom, and redemption, and irony of life, and celebration of silent film. Not children. Not art house adults who would snicker at the heroics. My only guess, this is a film by Tarsem for Tarsem, and we are the incidental audience. 

Watch it for images, the dance sequences, the roving, flowing camerawork. Every shot is worthy of a picture frame. Just don’t expect a “Tree of Life” life-altering experience. Cool bonus points: Most of the scenes between Pace (poor sap starred in “Marmaduke”) and the adorably hard-to-understand Untaru are improvised, the actor playing quick off her rambling talk and mistaken readings that only a child can provide, unscripted. It works beautifully up into the film’s tone goes crocodile tears. Bravo beautiful effort, though. B-

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Synecdoche, New York (2008)

Charlie Kaufmann is a mad comic film genius. In the opening of his mind-blasting epic comic-drama “Synecdoche, New York,” he shows a theater director (Philip Seymour Hoffman) dragging himself out of bed, lumping over to the bathroom then down to the kitchen, and walking by his wife and toddler daughter. It’s a grim, boring morning, and he seems miserable, all self-absorbed about not feeling well and blah-blah-blah. He reads the obits first, maybe waiting to see his own name. The radio, the newspaper’s A section, a milk carton, the B-Section, they all flash-forward dates –September, October, November and December. Caden Cotard is watching his life flash by, and he doesn’t appear to notice.

This essentially is the film. When his crap luck hits bottom, he begins a massive autobiographical play, literally staging his own life, as director and spectator, controlling and watching at the same time. Then he loses control of that, trying to rewrite his own script. This is just a quick snatch of the massive story from the writer of “Being John Malkovich” and “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.” What makes the brain, heart and soul connect and work is a Kaufman obsession, and Hoffman is freakin’ brilliant. (Has he ever not been?) But as the film comes to its end, and Cotard becomes more disconnected from himself -- actors are playing actors playing the actors playing him -- the movie loses steam. But maybe that’s the point. That's how we all die, in old age, is it not?

“Synecdoche” disappears in literal smoke, burned up by Kaufman’s unending, almost self- indulgent imagination. “Being” and “Eternal” are personal favorites. This one goes for the same arena, but comes just short of the mark. The concept is just a bit too far wide. But it’s a glorious, brave, wildly imaginative concept. The cast of supporting players includes Catherine Keener, Diane Weist, Tom Noonan, Michelle Williams, Emily Watson and Samantha Morton.

I loved the little bits, even the teeth-gnashing conversations one has with a toddler – “I have blood! I don’t want blood!” “You don’t have blood, dear.” “Don’t tell her that!” There wasn’t a stranger film I saw released in 2008, but it’s these bits that nail life dead center. For better and worse. It certainly makes one wake up and appreciate now, quickly dumping the end credits to go in and see how your wife is doing down the hallway. And, maybe, that’s really the point. A-

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Incendiary (2008)

“Incendiary” is the most insulting, exploitive film I’ve seen to tackle Islamic terrorism and mass death. It’s an awkward, miserable watch barely saved by Michelle Williams’ performance, which itself sinks to hysterical wailing. Williams plays a London mom, devoted to her child, but unhappily married to a bomb squad technician. At a bar one night, she meets a rich (!) investigative reporter (Ewan McGregor) who takes her home. They screw. When he comes to her place days later, they do it again. During, she watches the telly as her boy and hubby die in a stadium bombing. The silly title is partial literal as mom starts a diary – get it? – as if it were written to Bin Laden. “Incendiary” sinks into its own asshole with hubby’s boss announcing his love to the destroyed woman, McGregor stalking her with notepads, government conspiracies, and all sorts of nonsense too ridiculous to repeat. Every other minute, the film becomes more sensationalistic and sickly insipid. The most grievous sin: A happy ending that made me sneer. D

Wednesday, October 20, 2010

Man on Wire (2008)

“Man on Wire” is many films in one: Heist-like flick, a stunt film that makes “Jackass” seem quaint as Quakers, a documentary with talking heads, and a history/celebration of the World Trade Center and American inspiration. The story is true: In 1974, French daredevil high-wire artist Philippe Petit and some co-conspirators scammed their way inside the world’s tallest skyscrapers, and for some 45 minutes, Petit traipsed a wire strung between the two buildings. The plan was and is mind-shattering; the images – the reality – more so. Director James Marsh lays out a brilliant film, using interviews, old film, still photos, printed police reports, TV snippets, brilliantly acted reconstruction and even animated maps, to tell this tale. Petit is mesmerizing, and his surname ironic. This heroically foolish guy stood on air in the middle of the Twin Towers. Amazing! Marsh never mentions 9/11. Thank God. Why give homage to mass killers? This is a celebration of life, lived on the edge, and between the edges. A

Wendy and Lucy (2008)

“Wendy and Lucy” is a short story of a film, which provides no pretense or even a clear future. Michelle Williams is Wendy. Lucy is her dog. Wendy is a 20-something woman making her way from Indiana to Alaska, stuck in Oregon. With no past, we only know that Lucy is desperate to stay off the grid, has precious little money and her car just died. Then Wendy is arrested in a sorry attempt at shoplifting. The next ax? Lucy goes missing. That’s it, but enough. This struggle of one woman is plenty drama enough, and damn heart-tugging, especially her interaction with a grandfatherly security guard. (And that dog!) Director/co-writer Kelly Reichardt never pushes any envelopes, even during a tense seen with a man in the woods at night, but shows life as it is … unknowable, confusing and harsh, but also quite nice when a stranger provides kindness. Williams is amazing. A-

Monday, September 20, 2010

The Love Guru (2008)

Early in “The Love Guru,” Mike Myers appears to shove his head up his own ass. That is the perfect metaphor for this dismal comedy about America’s love for feel-good spiritual nonsense. Myers plays Guru Pitka, a India-raised Canadian who dives into the “heal thyself” shtick to meet girls. Ben Kingsley, always ready to befoul his “Gandhi” Oscar, is the mentor who makes his pupils fight with mops soaked in piss. That’s the level of humor here: Pee, poop, boobs, penises, fat people and everything else that makes third graders and Myers laugh. Jessica Alba, looking self-conscious, is the love interest. Myers can’t even find a point. Is he making fun of flakes like Deepak Chopra, or honoring them? Pitka is too idiotic to make any dent, while Chopra is treated as a star. Val Kilmer, Kanye West and Mariska Hargitay (whose name is a punch line) stop by for dead-air cameos. The entire film is tone deaf, and woefully unfunny. “Guru,” kill thyself. F

Thursday, August 19, 2010

Body of Lies (2008)

“Body of Lies” is a horrible title. But it sure beats “Generic, Unconvincing Middle Easy Spy Movie.” The name it deserves.

Ridley Scott’s thriller starts off with a bang – a busted group of Islamic Jihadists blow themselves up inside a block of English row houses without so much as a shrug. The scene shocks. Then we jump to hot, dangerous Iraq where super CIA spy Roger Ferris (Leonardo DiCaprio) is digging and running to nail a second cell of Jihadists. The mission goes to hell, and Roger is wounded. That’s the first half hour. I liked it.

Then the show falls apart. Roger is sent to Jordan by his boss (Russell Crowe) to bust another cell. The job goes to shit and injured again, Roger starts digging on a local nurse. Because that’s what white-as-rice American spies do in the hostile Middle East, date Muslim women in public and play grab hands, as to not get noticed. Everyone notices. Dogs even perk their ears. DiCaprio, sporting a beard that looks like arm pit hair, can’t push this slop to credibility. He’s too eager to please, and why is a war-scarred spy all gaga over a woman? And why does she believe his flimsy cover story? Because the script demands that the hero be compromised. No other reason.

Roger isn’t even actually a character, a person to root for. He’s an ideal – the young, pragmatic, justice-seeking American who wants to vanquish evil, but with utmost care for the innocent. Crowe also plays a symbol – the fat, pretentions, know-it-all American who doesn’t care if he’s right or wrong, and can’t tell the difference because he’s busy driving the minivan. Crowe is good, but his character is white noise. Debates about war far flat: Good guys want the war to end, but the bad guys don’t. Deep.

Scott’s best playing card is the might of tech-savvy U.S. surveillance, and the way terrorists stay out of sight by staying off the grid, all hand-written messages, bicycles and 1,000-B.C. hideouts. This is perfect entertainment for 2000. An unlikely dud from Scott. Bag this “Body.” C

Saturday, July 10, 2010

W. (2008)

Oliver Stone’s “W.” is a draft screenplay looking for a reason to exist. This portrait of George W. Bush (played by Josh Brolin) was released in theaters well before the 43rd president handed over the White House keys to Barack Obama. Why the rush? Rather than go bare-knuckle serious and deep as in “Nixon,” this desperate satire tosses stale “SNL” jokes at the audience, hoping for a giggle. The “humor” consists of Bush getting rat-fucked at a college party and later choking on a pretzel as the Prez. Stone has nothing substantial to say, and treats his title character as a dumb-struck audience member to his own life. The lame attempts at dream psychology are middle school at best. Shockers are the juice of Stone’s best work. Yet there are none here. Conspiracies about oil grabs, Bush marching to God’s drum, or Cheney’s plans for a world ruled by an all-powerful America, like Rome before Christ, are nothing new to anyone with a New Yorker subscription in 2006. Stone treats each revelation with hushed awe. I yawned. The cast is stellar, especially Richard Dreyfuss as a Cheney, and barely save the film. C-

Monday, June 7, 2010

Waltz with Brashir (2008)

Picasso’s “Guernica” has come to life. The Israeli animated documentary film “Waltz with Brashir” is the first cartoon (too light a word I know, I can’t think of another) that has left me absolutely speechless with horror and sadness over man’s constant desire to kill because his God is better than the other guy’s God.

“Waltz” is told from the perspective of writer/director Ari Folman, a veteran of the Israeli Army, who fought and killed in a 1982 war with neighbor Lebanon. While there, Folman witnessed a massacre of hundreds of Muslim men, women and children by vengeful Christian militants and his own troops, but doesn’t recall it.

That’s the peg of this film: Recalling the seemingly unforgettable. It’s a disturbing, beautifully told and painted tale with a hard “R.” As fellow veterans and then Folman speak of their memories, we see war action rendered in vivid, bloody detail, with chucks of almost expressionist imagery filling the screen. Blood, too.

Is the film accurate? I don’t know. It makes no bones about the tit-for-tat violence that religious zealots of all stripes visit upon each other, and even suggests that Israel’s war crimes can be compared a certain 20th century war demon.

That Folman fades to live action in the finale to show real unfathomable carnage – bullet-riddled, desecrated women and children and old men in piles – is a shock almost unbearable too watch. With “Presopolis,” the animated film genre has made some mind-bending strides in recent years. This is one of the best. A

Sunday, April 25, 2010

10,000 B.C. (2008)

In “10,000 B.C.” a young warrior (Steven Strait of “Sky High”) is hunting big hairy mammoths with his tribesmen one day and then chasing after the mysterious “four-legged demons” (that is, men on horses) who took his woman the next. This is a disaster movie of a different sort from Roland Emmerich, master of the Earth in Peril genre (“2012”). The set-up, including the temple climax is much like Mel Gibson’s 2006 adrenaline bloodbath “Apocalypto,” but made for little boys who gawk at the “PG-13” rating. I just yawned at the so-so actors mucking about as cavemen with bad wigs and clean shaven faces out of a Norelco commercial, fighting nothing more deadly than continuously bad CGI. Everything on screen -– languages, climates, animals, those pyramids -- are sure to give scientists and Creationists alike heart attacks as they fume over what’s correct. Me? The movie's not worth any effort. D+

Sunday, August 23, 2009

2008: Best and Worst

The Best
1. Slumdog Millionaire. Danny Boyle's tale of love conquering absolute poverty and evil is a punch to the gut, and a kick to the soul. This was the story that we, as a world, needed in 2008.
2. WALL-E. This easily could be No. 1. Pixar's tale of robots in a post-Earth world is instant classic. Truly inspirational work.
3. The Wrestler. Darren Aronofsky's portrait of a burned-out wrestler would bring Hulk Hogan to tears. One helluva film.
4. Man on Wire. A documentary about a oddball 1970s "crime" so cool, so now, it makes any modern heist flick seem sadly lame.
5. (Tie) The Dark Knight and Iron Man. Comic book movies done right -- bold, big and as smart as any written text. Fully re-watchable.
6. Waltz with Brashir. A war film documentary told in full animation. All cartoon rules are dead. Awesome film-making.
7. In Bruges. A bloody marvelous drama/comedy about two hitmen, one reeling from an error so grievous, it burns his soul.
8. (Tie) Let the Right One In and  The Orphanage. Two European horror films done right, both centering on children, one  vampire, the other, an Elephant Man-type misfit.
9. Frozen River. Do you love your momma? Well, she ain't nothing compared to Melissa Leo's brave soul here.
10. Milk. The story of Harvey Milk, an inspiring, brave American killed by classic American hatreds.


The Worst
5. Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skulls. Spielberg and Lucas trash one of the heros of my youth with CGI monkeys. No.
4. (Tie) 88 Minutes and Righteous Kill. Two reasons why Al Pacino and Robert De Niro are no longer Al Paciono and Robert De Niro.
3. The Love Guru. Was Mike Myers ever funny? From this film, the answer is ... No. Not a single laugh.
2. The Boy in the Striped Pajamas. The first and I hope the last Holocaust film made for children. It insults history.
1. Bangkok Dangerous. Even by the standards of bad Nicolas Cage flicks, this film excels in badness. A thriller with zero thrills.

Thursday, August 13, 2009

The Tale of Despereaux (2008)

"The Tale of Despereaux" is a beautiful-looking animated film. It literally looks like a magical children's book come to life. But this mouse is no Mickey, nor "Ratatouielle." (yeah, that's a rat. Sue me.) Despereaux (voiced by Matthew Broderick) doesn't even show until some 20 minutes in, but we get a far-cooler rat (Dustin Hoffman) up front. Err, why? There's a villain, a king, a princess and a castle, and nothing new. The story, such as it is, requires narration from Sigourney Weaver to stay afloat. Directors Sam Fell and Robert Stevenhagen got the visual eye candy down, but nothing else. As the credits roll, the film scurries from the mind like a mouse in a hole. C

Bedtime Stories (2008)

I could focus on how lame and unfunny the Adam Sandler family comedy "Bedtime Stories" is, but it's just not worth the effort. Sandler's haircut looks like Dustin Hoffman's cheap clip job from "Rain Man" and his hotel handyman character is about as funny as the elder Babbitt brother. But I'm more shocked that Guy Pearce ("Memento") is forced to mug here as the villain. Man looks as if he wants to forget making this film. Where has his career gone? British shock comedian/bad seed Russell Brand adds needed spark and fire with a few quick scenes. But who thought it was wise to let him near children? D-

Saturday, August 8, 2009

The Orphanage (2008)

"The Orphanage" ("El Orfornato") definitely comes from the mind of Guillermo del Toro, who directed "Pan's Labyrinth" and "Devil's Backbone." But Jan Bayona is the helmer here as del Toro only produced. Nevertheless, like those great films, this is a gorgeous gem dealing with children, death, supernatural forces and raw-nerve endings. This fascinating, unnerving film mixes, I kid you not, "Peter Pan" with "Poltergeist" with "The Elephant Man," with a heart-startling shot of startling originality and the nastiest "hit by a truck" scene you'll ever see. Plus the stomach punch found in Spanish films. This ain't no American "feel good" film. The ending puts a kick to the gut. A

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Milk (2008)

Sean Penn is life-changing in "Milk," the Oscar-winning biopic of gay civil rights leader Harvey Milk of San Francisco, slain on November 27, 1978 (the day my brother was born). Penn's entire body language, movement, even his smile and very eyes, disappear into the role of Milk, a NYC transplant who comes West in 1972 to open a small business.

Fed up with police abuse and constant bigotry from the political right, he soon becomes a community leader and then seeks city office. He gets the nod after multiple failed attempts and soon becomes the face of homosexuality in America. Is it any surprise he was murdered?

The cast of this mostly flashback-style biopic is amazing, from Emile Hirsch ("Into the Wild") as a young gangly hustler to Josh Brolin ("No Country for Old Men") as the angry conservative and fellow city supervisor who kills Milk and S.F. Mayor George Moscone (Victor Garber).

Dustin Lance Black's screenplay is a detailed wonder that balances dozens of characters and a good deal of history. But it's not a perfect beast. He and director Gus Van Sant ("Good Will Hunting") add in a double phone call between Milk and a suicidal gay teen - in a wheelchair! - that plays as way too sentimental and coy. Of course Milk inspired gay youths across the country to feel good about themselves, we don't need neon pointers.

Worse, the duo paints hell-bent White as a closeted gay man finally uncorked and brimming with rage. It's a weak, dumb and seriously cliched liberal argument. Here's the deal: self-righteous Bible-thumpers kill or harass gays for one reason, because they can. It makes them feel better about themselves and their God. There's nothing deeper or more secret than that cold evil fact. Heck, Brolin doesn't seem to cop to this card either. His slowly unraveling performance is brilliant.

That said, this is an uplifting film that uses real-life archival footage to great effect. (That really is Diane Feinstein announcing Milk and Moscone's deaths, and that really is Anita Bryant as one of God's bigots, err, believers.) But this is Penn's film, more so than "Mystic River." His Milk is geeky, shy, painfully trusting, jumpy in his own skin and prone to failed romances with immature or unstable men. He's much like any man, but he chases men. Not women. Who knew Penn had that in him.

Milk is not played as a hero or a saint, but a man who saw no one to lead his people and so became that leader. Penn deserves every accolade out there. A-

The Wrestler (2008)

"The Wrestler" is another gem from director Darren Aronofsky ("Requiem for a Dream"). Mickey Rourke, long absent from any decent film, plays Randy "The Ram" Robinson -- not his real name -- an ex-professional wrestler whose life stopped in 1990. He lives in a crap trailer that's as beat-up and meshed together as his own body, and he owns nothing made past the Reagan era. But he's not dead. Yet. This film nails lower class life in central New Jersey, the loneliness of boardwalks, and the life of middle-aged wrestlers living in Zombieland. (I once wrote a story on similar wrestlers. Writer Robert Siegel nails every reeking sweat-flop detail. It's like a documentary of that one weird night.) This is deep, poetic film about a simple man who can take the horrific physical violence of the ring, but not the emotional punches of life. One of 2008's Top 5. Rourke is amazing. A