Showing posts with label Sleuth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sleuth. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Sleuth (1972)

I saw the original “Sleuth” ages ago, whilst in college, and remember it as highly entertaining, a wild cinematic shape shifter, turning in on itself repeatedly as a cuckolded old man of wealth (Laurence Olivier) invites the hairdresser (Michael Caine) sleeping with his wife to his home for a cruel game of psychological torture. But the tables turn, and the characters onscreen one-up each other, as do the actors, classic theater thesp versus young hotshot sex symbol. I also recall it being painfully overlong, just one damn parlor trick too much. And, damn it, I hold at exactly that. Seriously, watch this film if you love acting, the way people play at bouncing off each other on screen, revealing -– and more importantly, holding back information -– until exactly the most painful or ludicrous moment. But beware, past the two-hour mark, you as I did, may get antsy and there’s 20 minutes to go. Based on a play, Anthony Shaffer’s screenplay desperately needs shortening. Olivier and Caine are beyond great, I can barely imagine the thrill of being on set. So watch. But squirm. Avoid the remake. B

Saturday, July 11, 2009

Sleuth (2007)

The new version of "Sleuth" has one thing going for it right out of the box: a witty, but simple, character-driven story of pure actor one-upmanship derived from the early-1970s classic film inspired by a play.
The story: A cuckolded husband (Michael Caine) dishes psychological torture on the man (Jude Law) sleeping with his wife. Then tables are turned. Then turned again. Caine, it should be noted, played the young man in the 1972 film, so that's also a huge plus. But this update sinks fast. Not because of the can-you-top-this actors, nor Harold Pinter's more nasty screenplay, but because director Kenneth Branagh constantly gets in the way of the story. His camera hangs from ceilings and fireplaces, it lurks behind window blinds, watches the actors through a television screen, sits still as actors walk off, stares at a nostril or eyeball for whole minutes. It plays like a hyperactive film student's thesis project. In essence, Branagh is trying to one-up his own actors as the true artist (Caine plays a writer/Law a would-be actor). The crap lighting and the gaudy art direction also compete as deadly distractions. Thankfully, it's short -- just under 90 minutes. C